Division: Are We Part of the Problem or Part of the Solution?
When we look around today, it is easy to feel overwhelmed by the amount of division we see. At times it seems worse than anything in recent memory, as if forces—both seen and unseen—are working to unravel not only our country, but much of the world. Politics divides us. Religion divides us. Race, culture, economics, education, and even the sources from which we receive our news can divide us. Families have stopped speaking to one another over political disagreements. Churches have split over doctrine. Friends who once enjoyed each other’s company can suddenly see one another as opponents because of a label attached to a belief.
Of course, division is nothing new. It has been woven through human history from the beginning. Tribes fought tribes, nations fought nations, religions fought religions, and sometimes people within the same religion fought each other over whose interpretation was correct. Human beings have always had a remarkable ability to separate the world into us and them. What has changed, in my opinion, is the internet. The internet exposes more, amplifies more, and provides a platform for voices—helpful and harmful alike—to spread their message far beyond what was possible in earlier generations. There was a time when an angry comment might have been spoken across a fence, around a dinner table, or at the local coffee shop. Today that same comment can travel around the world in minutes.
Social media can make this even worse. The most thoughtful voice is not always the loudest voice. Anger gets attention. Outrage gets shared. Fear keeps people watching. Before long, we can begin to believe that the most extreme voices represent everyone on the other side. But perhaps there is another side to this that deserves our attention. The internet may amplify division, but it did not create what it amplifies. Anger, fear, pride, jealousy, resentment, tribalism, insecurity, and the desire to be right have been part of the human experience for thousands of years. Technology has simply given these things a much larger stage.
That raises a more uncomfortable question: Where does division actually begin?
It is very easy to see division in someone else. We see it in politicians, churches, political parties, social media, nations, families, and communities. We can quickly point out the anger, hypocrisy, prejudice, intolerance, or blindness of those with whom we disagree. It is much harder to recognize the small ways division begins within ourselves. Every time we reduce another human being to a label, we have already begun separating ourselves from them. Every time we assume we know someone’s motives without actually knowing them, something happens within us. Every time we refuse to listen because we have already decided that the other person has nothing worth hearing, the wall becomes a little higher. Every time anger speaks through us before understanding has had a chance, we may be adding another small piece to the very problem we complain about.
This does not mean that all ideas are equally good or that truth does not matter. Some ideas should be challenged. Some behavior should be opposed. There are times when we need to speak clearly, draw boundaries, defend others, and stand firmly for what we believe is right. But there is a tremendous difference between opposing an idea and hating the person who holds it. Perhaps one of the greatest mistakes we make is believing that unity requires agreement. It does not. Two people can disagree strongly and still respect one another. We can hold deep convictions without turning those who disagree with us into enemies. We can say, “I believe you are wrong,” without saying, in effect, “Because you are wrong, you are less worthy of my respect.” Learning how to disagree without hatred may be one of the most important skills our world needs to rediscover.
Jesus gave us a remarkably difficult instruction: love your enemies. Those words are easy to admire as a religious ideal. They are much harder to practice when someone has offended us, misunderstood us, challenged our beliefs, insulted us, or treated us unfairly. Yet perhaps Jesus was pointing directly toward one of the deepest roots of human division. Loving someone does not mean agreeing with them. It does not mean approving of everything they do. It does not mean refusing to confront wrongdoing, nor does it mean that we must continue in a harmful relationship. It means something much more difficult: refusing to allow hatred to take possession of us.
And this is where the issue becomes deeply personal. When someone says something that angers me, what happens inside me before I respond? What part of me suddenly rises to defend itself? Is it truth speaking, or wounded pride? Is it conscience, or fear? Am I trying to understand, or am I simply waiting for my turn to prove the other person wrong? Sometimes the very people who irritate us can become mirrors. They reveal things within us that we might never have noticed otherwise.
This is where self-observation becomes important. If I can notice anger arising before I become completely identified with it, something changes. There is suddenly a small space between what happened and how I respond. In that space I have a choice. I can react mechanically, or I can respond consciously. That small pause may not change the world, but it can change the next thirty seconds. Sometimes thirty seconds is all it takes to prevent an argument, save a friendship, or stop a hurtful sentence that can never completely be taken back.
The more I have thought about this over the years, the more I have come to believe that the healing of division has to begin much closer to home than Washington, our churches, the news media, or the internet. It begins with the person looking back at us in the mirror. We cannot control what millions of other people think, say, or do. We cannot force another person to listen, and we cannot make everyone see the world the way we see it. But we can begin observing ourselves. We can notice when fear is speaking. We can notice when pride needs to win. We can recognize when an old wound has been touched. We can ask ourselves, Which part of me is speaking right now? Will what I am about to say heal something, or deepen the wound?
There is another important piece of this. Most people believe what they believe for reasons that make sense from where they are standing. Their upbringing, experiences, disappointments, fears, education, family, religion, culture, and the people they trust have all helped shape the way they see the world. That doesn’t necessarily make their conclusions correct, but understanding why someone believes something can make it easier to see the human being behind the belief.
Once we see the human being, something changes. The Republican, Democrat, conservative, liberal, Christian, atheist, immigrant, wealthy person, poor person, or person from another culture is no longer merely a category. There is a person standing there—a person with fears, hopes, disappointments, dreams, wounds, and people they love, just as we have. Labels may sometimes be useful for describing ideas, but they become dangerous when they prevent us from seeing people. Maybe that is one of the great spiritual challenges of our time: learning to see the person behind the label.
This does not require us to abandon truth. In fact, if what we believe is true, we should not be afraid to examine it, question it, or hear another point of view. Truth does not become weaker because someone challenges it. Perhaps we should occasionally ask ourselves, Am I defending truth, or am I defending my identity? Those are not always the same thing. Sometimes a belief becomes so closely connected to our identity that questioning the belief feels like questioning us. Then a conversation stops being an exchange of ideas and becomes a threat. The defenses rise, listening stops, and the goal quietly changes from discovering what is true to winning the argument. That is where division often takes root.
So what can ordinary people do? How do we, as individuals simply trying to live our lives, help slow this rising tide of separation? Maybe we begin very small. We listen a little longer. We pause before reacting. We ask another question before making an accusation. We refuse to pass something along merely because it confirms what we already believe. We try to understand someone’s position before criticizing it. We notice when anger begins controlling the conversation. And perhaps most importantly, we remember that the person standing on the other side of an issue is still a human being.
These may seem like very small responses to a very large problem, but nearly every great division is ultimately made up of individual human beings reacting to one another. Division spreads from person to person. Fear spreads. Anger spreads. Resentment spreads. But perhaps something else can spread in exactly the same way. Understanding can spread. Patience can spread. Compassion can spread. Courage can spread. Love can spread. One person refusing to return anger for anger may influence another. One person willing to listen may change a conversation. One conversation may change a relationship. Changed relationships slowly change families, churches, communities, and perhaps eventually something much larger.
We spend a great deal of time asking what is wrong with the world. Perhaps occasionally we should ask a different question: What is happening within me that contributes to the world I see around me? That question places responsibility somewhere we can actually do something about it.
Many books, thinkers, spiritual traditions, and teachings confront these questions head-on. Over the coming posts, I hope to take a deeper look—not simply at the symptoms of division, but at its roots. Fear, identity, woundedness, pride, unconscious reactions, the need for approval, the need to belong, and our tendency to divide humanity into us and them all deserve closer examination. I plan to keep most reflections fairly short, though some may grow longer depending on where the ideas take us.
I don’t expect us to agree on everything. In fact, that would defeat part of the purpose. Instead, I hope we can learn to examine our beliefs, observe ourselves, listen to one another, and become a little more conscious of what we are contributing to the world around us. Because perhaps the question is not simply, “Who is causing all this division?” Perhaps the more useful question is:
“Am I becoming part of the division—or part of the healing?”
Leave a comment. I would especially like to hear your thoughts: What do you believe is driving so much division today, and what can an ordinary person actually do about it? We will continue with the post About Me.



